"I see that there are a lot of capturing programs (like: VirtualVCR, iuVCR, Virtualdub, VirtualdubMod, AVIO, FLYDS and more), which one should I use?"

In principle you could try all of them, but there are some catches. There exists two device driver models: VfW (Video for Windows) and WDM (Windows Driver Model). The capture programs VirtualVCR, iuVCR and FLYDS support WDM, and Virtualdub, VirtualdubMod and AVIO support VfW. But a capture driver is based on one of those device driver models. In principe you should stick on the following:

• If your capture driver supports VfW, use a VfW capture program like: Virtualdub, VirtualdubMod or AVIO.
• If your capture driver supports WDM, use a WDM capture program like: VirtualVCR and iuVCR.
• If your processor is fast enough (say 1.5 GHz), you can use the available VfWWDM wrapper, to use any kind of capture program (assuming you want to capture at full resolution).

Some general information about VfW and WDM:

• VfW is old (and not being developed any more) and because of its limitations, Microsoft has come up with a new device driver model: WDM (supported natively starting from Windows 2000).
• Most video capture drivers are now being developed using WDM.
• There is a VfWWDM wrapper which enables you to capture in Virtualdub (or other VfW based capture programs) using WDM drivers. But you need a fast processor when using this wrapper, since it produces a high CPU load.
• VfW will continue to be supported in Windows 98, Windows 2000, Windows NT and Windows XP, but most of the times the card driver is the problem. Newer cards simply don't have VfW drivers, and only Hauppauge has VfW drivers for W2K and XP.
• VfW has no TvTuner support, while WDM has.
• Don't install DirectX 9.0b! The problem is that your TV input stops working, have a look at this thread.
• You can face different kind of problems: can't capture with WDM based capture programs keeping video and audio sync., can't capture at full resolution using the VfWWDM wrapper, etc. If you have similar problems, don't hesitate to ask for help in the Capturing video forum at doom9!

• WDM drivers for bt8x8 chips: btwincap (you could have some troubles with installation and usage, sound appears to be mono) or iulab tweaked wdm driver.

• WDM and VfW drivers which are supposed to work under Windows 98, Windows 2000, Windows NT and Windows XP (but they don't let you capture at full resolution though).

References:
WDM Video Capture Overview: General VfW and WDM information, states also the advantages of WDM.
Capture using Video for Windows: The timeline of VfW and WDM.
Video Capture: More general info about VfW and WDM.
VfWWDM wrapper: The download link can be found in question 14.

Next: Capturing: with VirtualDub or with VirtualVCR

Back to the index: <HOME>

Last edited on: 09/18/2003 | First release: n/a | Author: Wilbert | Content by Doom9.org